Search Site
Menu
Call for a FREE Consultation 973 676-1555

How Much Do Car Insurance Costs Increase After an Accident?

How Much Do Car Insurance Costs Increase after an accident in NJ

Were you recently in an auto collision? After making sure everyone is alright, your next thought might be, “What is this going to cost me?”

When you file a claim with your car insurance provider, you’re asking the company to foot the bill for your medical expenses, car repairs, and other costs associated with the accident. As a result, your monthly premium may increase following the accident.

Average Car Insurance Rate Increase After an Accident

On average, car insurance rates go up by 48% after getting in a crash. New Jersey drivers face a slightly steeper penalty averaging 59%. The exact amount your insurance company increases your rate depends on these factors:

  • Who was at fault? Whoever caused the accident is penalized the most, but even if you’re not at fault, your rate may increase by 12%. This is especially likely in a no-fault state like New Jersey, where each driver’s insurance company pays their policyholder’s medical bills, regardless of fault. Your insurance may also have to pay if an uninsured driver is at fault.
  • What was the extent of the damage? Accidents resulting in higher property damage, medical bills, and other costs come with higher penalties.
  • What are your insurance provider’s policies? If you have accident forgiveness, you shouldn’t see an insurance rate increase after being in a collision—unless you receive multiple citations. In that case, your insurer may forgive one but not the others, resulting in a smaller rate increase.
  • What is your driving history? Accident forgiveness may only apply to one crash within a specific timeframe. Do you have a history of accidents, moving violations, license suspensions, DUIs, and other infractions? Your insurer may view you as high-risk and raise your rate after each incident.

How Long Increased Insurance Rates Last

The penalty period is typically three to five years, coinciding with how long the accident stays on your driving record. Your insurer may decide to extend this period if your accident includes a DUI conviction, serious bodily injury or death, reckless driving, or excessive tickets during the penalty period.

How to Reduce Car Insurance Costs After an Accident

Whatever you do, don’t forgo car insurance to save money. It’s illegal and dangerous. You could also be fined up to $1,000 or have your license suspended if you drive without liability coverage in New Jersey.

Fortunately, there are other ways to lower your insurance costs:

  • Increase your deductible
  • Lower your coverage
  • Drive more carefully
  • Don’t file a claim if the damages cost less than your deductible
  • Shop for a new provider

When You Need an Attorney

Are you seeking compensation for your injuries after a car crash? Hire an auto accident lawyer in New Jersey to help you get the money you deserve! Contact Gelman Gelman Wiskow & McCarthy LLC at 862-263-0770 today for a free consultation. We would be happy to discuss the circumstances surrounding your car accident and answer any questions you have.

$800,000.00 settlement in less than nine (9) months!
In September of 2025, Phil Wiskow settled a legal malpractice case, resulting from a botched personal injury case, for $800,000.00. Most significantly, Mr. Wiskow settled the case less than nine (9) months after the client hired him. Since the client settled his botched case for over $200,000.00, the full amount of the client's recovery exceeded one million dollars.
Settled his 60 year old client’s motorcycle accident case for $1,700,000.00
In the Spring of 2017, Phil Wiskow settled his 60 year old client’s motorcycle accident case for $1,700,000.00. Frankly, the case would have settled for more money but the most culpable party only had a $300,000.00 liability insurance policy. The firm’s client, who was already disabled and receiving social security benefits at the time of his accident, sustained multiple lower leg fractures–which ultimately resulted in numerous surgeries and an above the knee amputation–when a delivery van blindly backed out of a loading dock and pinned his leg against his bike. The majority of the client’s settlement money was paid by the owner of a tractor-trailer and the lessee of the loading dock whose dangerous loading and unloading procedures blocked the van driver’s view of the motorcycle and the firm’s client’s view of the van.
VERDICTS & SETTLEMENTS
  • In the Spring of 2020, Phil Wiskow settled a motor vehicle/motorcycle accident case for the Defendant’s 1.3M policy limit. The terms of the settlement are confidential.
Our Offices
  • East Orange Office
    60 Evergreen Place
    Suite 502
    East Orange, New Jersey 07018
    Phone: 973 676-1555
    Fax: 973-675-5674
  • Elmwood Park Office
    One Broadway
    Suite 102
    Elmwood Park, New Jersey 07407
    Phone: 973 676-1555
    Fax: 973-675-5674
  • Pompton Plains
    142 Route 23 North
    Pompton Plain, New Jersey 07444
    Phone: 973 676-1555
    Fax: 973-675-5674
  • Avon by the Sea
    416 Garfield Avenue
    Avon by the Sea, New Jersey 07717
    Phone: 973-713-4667
    Fax: 973-713-1565